A few more thoughts about big money in politics

Yesterday I did a little reading and learned that money can’t really buy elections.

But when it’s evaluated and facts are set out, it becomes complicated. Not because money can buy elections (it can’t), but because so much money is being poured into elections and all that money is driving people crazy. There’s a false perception springing out of this that the guy who has the most money is going to be the winner.

The tenor of the craziness seems to be: if $billions are being spent on election campaigns, well…it has to mean something, right? It has to have an effect.

Nah. It doesn’t.

But I have learned something that explains why at this moment, pre-election day, I’m reading tons of tweets from candidates claiming they’re winning, or are close to winning and if we help them with money, it’d be great.

They’re doing this because of what must be a strategy developed by political psychologists: candidates who are thought to be winning will pull in more money than candidates who are seen to be behind in the race.

Back in 2016, I started wondering about the money argument. I started to think that all the conversation about big money in campaigns, as well as the garish display of big money in campaigns, was possibly de-sensitizing us to its power. That is, if — and I think it’s a big if — at one time after Citizens United some people were impressed by pounding campaign ads, isn’t it reasonable to think that those people are not paying avid attention anymore?

Ask yourself this: have you seen a campaign ad that’s influenced you to change your mind about the candidate you support, i.e., to shift your vote to the other guy?

If so, I guess you’re the kind of person who has laid out big bucks for Prevagen.

I firmly, loudly believe that campaign contributions should not be coming from Dark Money PACs, or corporations, or very rich people, beyond the contribution limits I live within as an individual donor. I would like our politics to be publicly financed. Therefore, I’m a fervent supporter of Sheldon Whitehouse’s DISCLOSE Act which, thanks to the Senate GOP, did not pass a few months ago.* And I’d love Citizens United to be demolished any which way it can.

But Dark Money isn’t forcing Georgia voters to hail Marjorie Taylor Greene as their personal demon-busting savior, while the vast rest of us sit around shaking our heads over  how the fuck did this appalling, dopey reality TV performer wind up in Congress.

So let’s look at the bright light in all this big money political furor. Which is that a bunch of loathsome, repulsively rich people are flinging their $$$ out, thinking they’re actually affecting elections.

Remember, every $billion spent by those horrible people means one less megayacht in their portfolio. Is it possible that their “investments” in political candidates is about to go belly-up and leave them fingering their cryptocoins in a padded room? On their yacht?

Why not?

*One more good piece of legislation that will be re-presented and passed — if the Democrats get a majority in the Senate and keep a majority in the House.

Posted in Capitalism, Corruption, Government, Joe Biden and his people, political campaigns, Politics, Propaganda, The Facts of Life, The filthy rich, Trumpism, TV commercials, voting and voting rights | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A few more thoughts about big money in politics

Where is the proof that money can buy elections?

Yesterday I was talking to my cousin Thomas, a resolute pessimist, about the upcoming election. He asked, “Is there any hope?”

I’m afraid I snapped at him. (Optimists can snap, you know. We don’t bite but we snap.) His response was to gloom over how much money was going into the election, and I said, “There is no evidence that money can buy elections.”

Today, I decided to fact check myself on that. Has anyone — I mean anyone credible — done a research study on the subject?

It’s easy enough for data collectors to add up how much money goes into each race, and learn who wins those races. But has someone designed a protocol for analyzing cause and effect here?

I thought about when I worked at Paramount Pictures, and about whether money which the company poured into advertising and promoting our films was worth it. I got an answer from my friend Warren Lieberfarb: What sells a film best is a friend coming up to you, grabbing you by the lapels and saying, “You’ve GOT TO SEE THIS MOVIE!”

Peer pressure, I suppose it’s called.

But I don’t know whether peer pressure affects elections any more than big money does.

So I did my own research, i.e., I Googled “evidence whether money buys elections.” I came up with a 2018 article from 538, “How Money Affects Elections.”

An odd article but really fascinating. You read a section subtitled something like “The candidate who spends the most money usually wins,” but the rest of the section disputes the title. Because, as the article points out, money is attracted to someone who is perceived as going to win. Where does that perception come from? Well, polls mostly. And what is evaluated as “insider info.” That is to say, very rich people want to put money into candidates which “insiders” say can win.

But who are those “insiders”? Newt Gingrich? Karl Rove? Mitch McConnell?

Presumably, all that money is going to buy somebody an election. In reality, though, [it] isn’t quite right. Political scientists say there’s not a simple one-to-one causality between fundraising and electoral success. Turns out, this market is woefully inefficient. If money is buying elections a lot of candidates are still wildly overpaying for races they were going to win anyway. And all of this has implications for what you (and those big dark money donors) should be doing with your political contributions.

More:

That’s not to say money is irrelevant to winning, said Adam Bonica, a professor of political science at Stanford who also manages the Database on Ideology, Money in Politics, and Elections. But decades of research suggest that money probably isn’t the deciding factor in who wins a general election, and especially not for incumbents.

But wait. What about all those TV ads we keep seeing as the election draws near.

Advertising — even negative advertising — isn’t very effective

This is a big reason why money doesn’t buy political success. Turns out, advertising, the main thing campaigns spend their money on, doesn’t work all that well.

Has anyone done a thorough, valid study of the effect of money on elections?

Driven by fears that attack ads might undermine democracy by reducing voter turnout, researchers have been looking at the impacts of negative advertising since the 1990s. And, beginning around the mid-2000s, they began making serious progress on understanding how ads actually affect whether people vote and who they vote for. The picture that’s emerged is … well … let’s just say it’s probably rather disappointing to the campaigns that spend a great deal of time and effort raising all that money to begin with.

So. Money may have an effect on an election but only if the candidate himself has been positively affecting his chances in the election.

And until a political scientist does a solid study of money vs elections, I’ll be sticking to my idea. Money can’t buy elections.

Ω

Oh, and polls? Here’s the little story I related a few years ago about polls:

The original British TV series, House of Cards, starring the perfectly wonderful, slimy, sexily evil Ian Richardson as Francis Urquhart, had several sequels. In the second, To Play the King, Urquhart has finagled and, yeah, murdered his way to becoming Prime Minister. He retains a brilliant (and beautiful) pollster, Sarah Harding, as an advisor.

The scene embedded in my brain: Urquhart (pronounced “Irkit,” in case you want to read this out loud), is having political problems. If I remember correctly, they’re due to his government’s racist policies about which protests and riots have sprung up. His popularity is fading fast.

What to do? He might have to dissolve his government and call for elections. But Sarah has another idea. “We’ll do a poll,” she says.

“But won’t the results be bad for me?” Urquhart argues.

“Oh no,” says Sarah. Slyly. “Getting the results we want depends entirely on the questions we ask.”

Ω

What definitely affects the outcome of an election? Voting. We don’t vote per the polls. We don’t vote with the polls. Forget the polls, forget Citizens United.

The only united citizens that matter are we citizens, as we unite to vote.

Posted in Capitalism, Corruption, Government, political campaigns, Politics, Propaganda, The Facts of Life, Trumpism, TV commercials, voting and voting rights | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Where is the proof that money can buy elections?

P.S. On reading while watching TV

Why do I read while watching TV?

Guilt.

My mom did not like the television. In fact, she hated it. Along with many others, she called it “the idiot box.” So we had rules involving when we could watch TV and what we could watch.

The TV was in the dining room, tucked into the corner right next to the kitchen, where we ate. Dinner time was one of those times when we were not allowed to watch TV.

One night, though, there was something on TV, I don’t remember what, which could not be ignored, it was that important. So important, I don’t remember what it was. Whatever it was, though, caused the TV to emit an incantation which put us into a spell. We three kids coped as subtly as possible. We did not rush into the dining room en masse. One at a time we’d get up from the table and slip very quickly to the doorway from which we could peer at the TV for a couple of seconds before returning to our chairs.

One at a time. You know, so my mom wouldn’t notice one of us was missing for a few seconds.

My mother sat there stewing. Until she got up, walked into the dining room and kicked the TV in. I mean, she broke it. Whatever we were watching was gone. So was the TV for the week it took the repair shop to fix it.

My mother exhibited no guilt whatsoever. In retrospect, I found her power and physical strength awesome. But I’ve had guilt about watching “the idiot box” ever since.

My mom’s spirit is omnipresent in my life, so that’s why I read while being TV-ed. But mom had a good, impish sense of humor; I can feel her smiling as she watches me read in front of the TV. She knows I’m cheating, I know I’m cheating. And anyway, I think she’d like this British crime show.

Posted in The Facts of Life | Tagged | Comments Off on P.S. On reading while watching TV