Two reasons to watch the Jan 6 hearing tonight

On January 6, 2021, I had the TV on, I’m not sure why. It was daylight and I never have the TV on in daylight. At the same time, I was on the phone with my cousin Thomas.

Then there came a moment when I interrupted our conversation to say, “You’ve got to turn the TV on now, you have to see this.” What I was viewing at that moment was a Black policeman, whom I now know to be Eugene Goodman, running up a wide marble staircase while being pursued by members of a white mob.

Only later did I learn that Officer Goodman was deliberately leading the mob away from the congresspeople the mob was hunting.

What we’ll see tonight and in subsequent broadcasts is actual, moving American history, before it’s inscribed in books. We will see the living record of an stunning event that had never happened in this country before.

I see two reasons which might induce you to watch:

If you’re part of the majority, you want to know what happened and who did what to whom. You’re not afraid of the facts, the reality.

If you’re part of the minority, you’ll want to get off on the violence.

 

Posted in Government, Jan 6, Lawyers, Politics, Propaganda, The Facts of Life, voting and voting rights | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Two reasons to watch the Jan 6 hearing tonight

Why are likely Jan 6 defendants so nonchalant about going to prison?

I’ve spent some time thinking about this.

Among some quick and easy answers:

  • They don’t fully understand what they’re facing, because…
  • They are appallingly ignorant about our history, our laws, our prosecutorial agencies such as the DOJ, and our conventions. And I’m being kind to call them “ignorant;” they are also not smart. Which is also being kind.
  • They believe — because they’ve been told by manipulators — they’re on the right side of history and will be acquitted.
  • They’ve been told they’ll be fine because of the Supreme Court. (See above, re their ignorance about our laws.)
  • They’ve been told that when Trump wins in 2024, he’ll pardon them.
  • They’ve been convinced — by manipulators — that prison will be no big deal, and will indeed be an honorific.

Ah, that last one…

Quite coincidentally, over the past couple of years I’ve read biographies of Trotsky and Lenin and have connected those radicals’ histories with what’s been going on here in America.

As well, I’ve become vaguely aware that the “intellectual” maven for this radical American terrorism is Steve Bannon. And Steve Bannon has professed himself to be a Leninist, whatever he thinks that means.

Really, I’m not going to attempt to enter Bannon’s head to figure out what he thinks Leninism is, in great part because he’s an opportunistic poseur who will pay lip service to anything that’ll win him attention. (So many MAGA egos, all competing for attention.)

There are a number of things I would say about Lenin. The central one, though, is he was an awful person. (So, indeed, was Trotsky.) I loathed him.

Reading a fine biography of any subject means spending a lot of intimate time with the subject, and spending time with Lenin was such a bummer, I was able to read only a few pages every night before getting nauseous and dyspeptic.

But that’s not why I’m referring to him here. Lenin, Trotsky and the whole Bolshevik cohort called themselves professional revolutionaries and worked at this profession from early adulthood. Promoting their revolutionary ideas in Tsarist Russia, with its vicious secret police, the Okhrana, entailed a number of arrests and being thrown into one prison or another.

Hitler went to prison, too, after the failed Beer Hall Putsch.

Even under Tsarist overseers, the Russian revolutionaries did not suffer much in prison. Nearly all of them were middle class, even upper middle class, and had all sorts of privileges in prison. Indeed, Trotsky felt prison was a great place to write.

Fairly regularly, the revolutionaries were sent into exile, into remote Russian towns and villages, where they lived, often with their wives and families, until they got restless and departed by walking to the nearest railway station and taking the train back to civilization, usually to countries that were not Russia.

Until they returned to Russia, to St. Petersburg, for the Revolution, which replaced one totalitarian state with another one, and the Okhrana with the Cheka.

It seems to me that a hot selling point of Leninism today may be that terms in prison on behalf of Trump are to be viewed as glamorous badges of honor. They convey authenticity and elevated status to these revolutionary wanna-be’s. They’ll come out in 5 or 15 or 20 years or so with tattoos proclaiming their membership in a cult, the commander of which is the empty suit that was Donald Trump.

So that’s why I think this band of violent bros think prison will be a breeze, a highlight of their future C.V.s. As I said, they’re not very bright. They surely don’t understand that the 2022 United States is nothing like 1900’s Russia.

Nothing.

 

 

 

 

Posted in Fascism, Government, Judiciary, Law, suits and order, Politics, The Facts of Life, Trumpism | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Why are likely Jan 6 defendants so nonchalant about going to prison?

Everyone is right to be furious over this NYT headline

Here’s the headline and the equally skiddy sub-head:

Jan. 6 Hearings Give Democrats a Chance to Recast Midterm Message

With their majority at stake, Democrats plan to use the six high-profile hearings to refocus voters’ attention on Republicans’ role in the attack.

So, okay, since I recently made a point over the frequent rages many smart people have over the Times’ headlines — and since I’m furious over this one — I’d better, um, address the situation and apply my own reasoning here. That is, let’s dissect this according to my perceptions about reading the news, especially headlines. Which, in summary, were and are:

Heightened language is used in headlines to…get your attention and prick you to read the article. I’ve always thought this was the purpose of a headline.

Once you get past the headline, a news article gives you the facts. Yes, each reporter uses his/her own language to bring the facts to life. But the facts are the facts and they are in there, in the article, no matter how they are tinted.

So does this headline hold up? Well, it apparently has done what I said headlines aim to: “get your attention and prick you to read the article.”

The headline did the first part. It pricked my attention by, first, stating “Jan. 6 hearings.” I want to read what the Times has to say about this huge event beginning on Thursday night, prime time.

But then what pricked my attention was how peculiarly off the point the rest of the headline was: “…Hearings Give Democrats a Chance to Recast Midterm Message: With their majority at stake, Democrats plan to use the six high-profile hearings to refocus voters’ attention on Republicans’ role in the attack.”

HUH? What nonsense is this before my eyes, in the Times font?

Where did the reporters get the notion that the purpose of the hearings — which clearly is to present evidence of the most massive and massively populated criminal activity against the United States and our government — is to “give Democrats a Chance…”

The biggest criminal investigation in the history of this country — and maybe any other country — is NOT a “chance to recast midterm message.” Nor did I hear or read anywhere that the Democrats “plan to use the…high-profile hearings to refocus voters’ attention on Republicans’ role in the attack.”

So what does this headline mean? Unless the article contains quotes from Democrats substantiating the headline POV, the headline is nothing more than a writer’s and/or editor’s perspective or speculation.

So now I go into the article. Do I find anything to suggest the headline has some accuracy, at least to the Democratic Party’s purposes? Immediately, I see the article — with a first paragraph replicating the suggestions in the headline — is written by Annie Karni and Luke Broadwater.

I have pretty high opinions of both journalists, especially with Broadwater’s reporting on the January 6 assault. So do they record any Democrat saying anything about these stated “intentions”? Not really.

But Democrats argue the hearings will give them a platform for making a broader case about why they deserve to stay in power.

What Democrats? Name ’em. Name at least one. That sentence is immediately followed by this quote:

“When these hearings are over, voters will know how irresponsibly complicit Republicans were in attempting to toss out their vote and just how far Republicans will go to gain power for themselves,” said Representative Sean Patrick Maloney, the Democratic campaign chair.

Uh-uh. What Maloney said can’t be interpreted as arguing for why the Democrats “deserve to stay in power.” Maloney made a straightforward and patently accurate statement about how anti-democratic the GOP has become. It’s not even a stretch to make the claim Karni and Broadwater are making. It falls splat on its face.

So is there anything more in the article to justify the headline?

Representative Hakeem Jeffries, Democrat of New York, said on Twitter that the hearings would “fully expose the cult’s extreme effort to overthrow the U.S. government.”

On Twitter? It’s a characteristically terse and strong quote from Jeffries but these reporters couldn’t get a direct quote from any Democrat to substantiate their own slant on the purpose and weight of the hearings.

Instead, they slight what they interpret as voters’ attention to the insurrection, and wonder in print about the opposition:

But they are facing an onslaught from Republicans who are bent on denying, downplaying and obfuscating the truth of what happened in their own messaging operation aimed at discrediting the inquiry.

What? What “onslaught”??

The GOP is so frightened of the hearings, Fox, their own propaganda network, will not be televising them — not even to have their Putin-fanatic talking heads yell arguments in real time. That’s how scared they are.

Yet, in the “fair and balanced” mode of irritating journalism, Karni (whose background is Politico, notorious for buzzy “hot stories” that fade under casual scrutiny) and Broadwater (Baltimore Sun, and he should know better), offer…Marco Rubio and Elise Stefanik:

“Instead of focusing on $5 gas, 6,000 illegal immigrants a day, record fentanyl deaths, or the violent criminals terrorizing America democrats use taxpayer money on a TV producer for the prime time political infomercial from the Jan 6th circus,” Senator Marco Rubio, Republican of Florida, said on Twitter on Monday.

You can take Rubio apart with both your eyes closed. (Methinks he shouldn’t have reminded his audience of “violent criminals terrorizing America,” because that’s exactly what they’ll be witnessing during the Jan 6 hearings.)

Representative Elise Stefanik of New York, the No. 3 Republican who was Mr. Trump’s chief defender during the first impeachment hearing, will oversee the effort to discredit the committee’s findings, coordinating with Representative Kevin McCarthy of California, the minority leader, and Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio, the top Republican on the Judiciary Committee. They plan to book Republican lawmakers on television to push a debunked claim that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi is to blame for the attack. [My bolding]

Oh, gee. Those claims will really win me over, especially when I note that several of the GOP leaders involved in attempts to discredit the Jan 6 Committee’s evidence are themselves heavily implicated in the insurrection. Their names may even be cited in the hearings as co-conspirators, or in future DOJ indictments.

So, does this article, despite the misleadingly subjective headline, do what I said an article has to do? No matter how brightly colored by a reporter’s language, does the article gives the facts?

Well, it doesn’t really. It’s dealing with an event in the near future and does not offer any more facts that we already have about that event. Instead, it’s imposing a purpose upon those facts, a purpose which is not in evidence.

So I guess I have to add a new category to news reporting. We have (1) news articles. We have (2) opinion essays about that news. And (3) we have reporters’ analyses of either what’s happened or what’s likely to happen.

This article is in the third category. And I, among many, think the analysis is highly slanted and way, way off the main highway, on a detour so bumpy it might have been chopped out by shovels yesterday.

The name of the main highway is mass sedition against the world’s longest-living democracy.

I believe that’s the road the Commission will take us on. Anything further the Democrats gain from it is peripheral to the purpose.

Posted in Law, suits and order, Politics, Propaganda, The Facts of Life, voting and voting rights | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Everyone is right to be furious over this NYT headline