On the subway…no, there was no shooting

My friend Andrea and I were at a downtown café talking about the subways. To wit, every time there’s news of a shooting on the subway, Andrea’s mother, not a New Yorker, calls her.

“You’re not going on the subway, are you?” says her frightened mother.

Andrea assures her that, yes, she will be going on the subway. Andrea has tried to explain to her family — all of whom do not live in New York — the subway is how we all travel and that bad incidents were rare. “I mean,” Andrea said, “what is she thinking? That the day after a shooting there’ll be another shooting?”

Occasionally we do see semi-crazy people on the trains. Some of them are endearing, some irritating. None I’ve seen over a lifetime of riding the trains has emitted waves of danger. (To be sure, I didn’t cozy up to the guy wearing a thick white scarf…which turned out to be a live python.)

I’d taken the subway to get downtown to see Andrea. As I left her to go back to the subway, she said, dryly, “Have an unremarkable trip.”

I got on the train at 14th Street and got a seat. Following me was a very small woman who sat opposite me. Now here’s the thing about being an aware, but not paranoid, New Yorker: right away I thought there was something odd about her. No, not dangerous. Just…strange.

There was nothing particular about her which I could identify as off. She was wearing a respectable sweater, a skirt, sandals with socks — well that might be a bit odd but all sorts of people in the city get their feet into sandals on the first hot day and don’t take them off until the snows come.

I thought her a tiny, old lady, even though I couldn’t see anything about her to pin down her age. She was wearing, as we all do in the subway, a mask over her mouth and nose, and a soft, black rimmed hat pulled so far down over her upper face, between the mask and the hat I couldn’t see her face or her eyes at all.

So that was a bit, I dunno, secretive.

Then, even before the doors closed, she put her fingers into her ears. Sometimes people do that. Sometimes subway brakes can shriek and, I guess, some people worry that the sound might make them deaf.

So, okay. Even if nothing was screechy or even loud. The conductor’s voice over the loudspeaker was at a pleasant pitch.

For the entire trip she sat there with her fingers pressed into her ears, like a child who was refusing to listen. I wondered if she were pressing on earbuds to hear music or something, but no. No earbuds. And no noise from the subway, either. The train was quiet enough for two riders to have a conversation in ordinary speaking voices.

72nd Street, my stop, was her stop, too. She rose, fingers still in her ears and, unlike the rest of us, didn’t grab a pole to steady herself as the train slowed and stopped. She wobbled, fingers in her ears, but did not fall over.

She removed her fingers to walk out the door but once she was on the platform, back into her ears went her fingers. She headed right and, since I headed left, I lost sight of her.

Perhaps I should have followed her to see whether she ever removed her fingers. But I was not that curious.

Posted in Guns in the U.S. of A., The Facts of Life | Tagged | Comments Off on On the subway…no, there was no shooting

What’s a pathological optimist to do when all about her is despair?

I just read today’s New York Times opinion section, after which I dipped into the readers’ comments, as I always do.

Despair, hopelessness, monumental depression — about us, the United States. Secession, too, had its proponents among my fellow readers, a mutually agreed upon secession. Not another violent Civil War, although it seems to me we’re already in one.

Reading the moroseness of so many deeply intelligent and concerned people was depressing. So I’m wandering off track into a field of wild, weird flowers.

I found the descriptive “pathological optimist” in the May 30 New Yorker’s The Talk of the Town section. It was applied by the pathological optimist himself, a Ukrainian writer (“I write in Russian. I am not a Russian writer…”) named Andrey Kurkov. With whom I am instantly in love.

He is not the first contemporary writer in Russian I’ve been in love with. He was Sergei Dovlatov.

The Wikipedia entry for Dovlatov is worse than unsatisfying; it seems to have been written by a hostile Soviet apparatchik. But I found that link above, to a James Wood review in the New Yorker of a posthumously published Dovlatov novel, Pushkin Hills. How had I missed getting and reading it? I will remedy this hole in my life.

(Pause, as I find a used but good hardcover edition on line. And buy it.)

Reading Wood’s wondrously luminous essay now reminds me why I am a pathological optimist.

Dovlatov was not published in Russia during his lifetime. During the 1970s, he circulated his writing in samizdat and began to be published in European journals, an activity which brought about his expulsion from the Union of Soviet Journalists in 1976. He left the Soviet Union in 1978…

As Wood says, Dovlatov’s work is an epic, often hilarious, discussion of freedom. Not “freedom,” the way we brandish the word casually, without any distinctive definition beyond a glorious, misty panorama, but the complicated and scary meaning of freedom to emigrés who came from a country where there was none.

“Dovlatov was not published in Russia during his lifetime.” Imagine that. Imagine living in a State which could gag you because It didn’t like the words you emitted, and even silence you when you weren’t there anymore. A State which didn’t appreciate the use of satire and absurdity to comment on Its criminal existence. If It really didn’t like you, you were disappeared.

At the top of this page, I mentioned reading a number of columnists in a major journal, the Times. A journal available to anyone with a local newsstand and/or internet access. Each of the columnists — Michelle Cottle, Paul Krugman, Jamelle Bouie, Michelle Goldberg — mourned the horror of dead children in school, the insanity of heavy weaponry owned by lunatics. Their readers’ comments unleashed worldwide fury over what has happened in this country.

Most pointedly, each columnist and reader excoriated the politicians who, in stupidity and fear of their own voters, refuse to do their jobs and ban weapons of mass destruction. Instead, what those politicans propose as solutions to our anguish is banning language, books, actual history, dissidents, people who don’t look and think like them. If children are shot in public schools, they will shut public schools — as they did throughout the South after the decision in Brown v Topeka.

What the minority party here is promising is a State like the old Soviet Union which Dovlatov condemned through satire, and the new, but similar Putin State which Andrey Kurkov now condemns through satire.

Satire is the asylum for creators who can only criticize obliquely to evade State punishment.

But not one of the Times’ columnists, not one of their readers used satire to convey their horror. They didn’t have to. We live in a country in which “cancel culture” doesn’t mean disappearance, doesn’t mean death.

On the floors of Congress, our elected representatives are breaking our hearts out loud in condemning what is happening, in asking and demanding that the GOP join them in enacting laws. Chris Murphy was on his knees, pleading for sanity.

On Twitter, people who are known to us, who are named, who are public figures, are not afraid to make their opinions known. And they name names, they condemn the GOP by individual name after name.

We all have that freedom to tell those names to fuck off.

This kind of freedom was dangerous and scary to Sergei Dovlatov, Soviet citizen, who had no mechanism for protesting. It isn’t dangerous or scary to me. Or you. After the despair will come action. Because that’s what freedom means here. It means a state of fluctuating but permanent revolution. We are not losing our freedom to Putin worshipers. They are in the minority, and they always will be.

We will conquer them the way we always do. We have had 237 years of practice improving and widening these freedoms.

We are the majority. We vote.

Posted in Guns in the U.S. of A., Human rights, The Facts of Life, voting and voting rights | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on What’s a pathological optimist to do when all about her is despair?

He was the capitalist archetype. He was a monster

Jack Welch was the longtime CEO of General Electric which became, under his tsardom, the most “valuable company in the world.”

In yesterday’s Times, David Gelles, the journalist who wrote the Corner Office column for the business section, yanked Welch’s dessicated corpse out of his grave to do an autopsy on his dominance and influence over American business.

The article, “How Jack Welch’s Reign at G.E. Gave Us Elon Musk’s Twitter Feed,” is adapted from Gelles’s new book, The Man Who Broke Capitalism.

After having worked for capitalists, I really did not want to learn more about Jack Welch. Back in those days, I hadn’t yet finalized the position of capitalism in my personal intellectual hierarchy. Still, I had queasy feelings about Jack Welch and his ilk, the tyrants of a system I came to see as amoral, necessarily counterbalanced by government, a democratic society’s effort at moral consensus.

Jack Welch was great at increasing profits and accumulating power for himself and his constituents, i.e,  shareholders. The way Welch went about doing so made him a monster.

I think I understand why Gelles called him “the man who broke capitalism,” although Welch himself didn’t. What he did do was inscribe a perversely vile way of doing big business. And he gave birth to a slew of business disciples who have fucked up the companies they have run the Welch Way.

Just after I read Gelles’ article, I spotted what follows in Harper’s June Index, which confirms in punchy numbers what Gelles describes fully in the article. Which is how those CEOs who followed Welch have screwed up:

Percentage of U.S. workers who quit their jobs in 2021 who cited disrespect as a reason for quitting: 57

Who cited overwork: 39

Who are now earning more than they were in 2021: 56

Percentage by which hiring a CEO with a business degree decreases wages for the company’s other employees: 15

Average percentage change in sales by companies that hire CEOs with business degrees: -1

But the wretched system called capitalism has not only survived Jack Welch. It has been transmuted by the Koch Bros, et al., into a political movement disingenuously called “libertarianism,” which drives not only at sucking as much money from consumers as possible while fighting pesky regulations.

Capitalism now seeks to destroy what it sees as the biggest obstacle to its absolutism: our democratic government.

 

Posted in climate change, Consumer boycott, Corruption, Government, Koch Bros Final Solution to Democracy, Politics, The Facts of Life, The filthy rich, The War On Workers | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on He was the capitalist archetype. He was a monster