War. I don’t get it. But then I’m a naive and foolish woman

I’ve just been listening to a panel of experts on Nicolle Wallace’s MSNBC show, opining critically on what is happening in Afghanistan.

I am, emotionally and intellectually, in a combination of sarcastic bewilderment and fury. With one exception, the experts and their host seem to have deleted (recent) history from their brains.

Let’s go back twenty years and recall why our mighty armed forces were in Afghanistan in the first place.

Reason number 1: the Bush administration, for whom Nicolle Wallace worked, ignored or shrugged off or failed to comprehend (because they were not particularly smart or attentive) intelligence that Al Qaeda intended a terrorist act against the United States probably using large aeroplanes.

Reason number 2: the Twin Towers in my beloved city were hit and collapsed. I recall this event fairly accurately. From a large window in my dentist’s office I watched the North Tower, bleeding and burning, when an immense ball of fire floated to the ground after the second plane hit the South Tower, not visible to us.

We did not know precisely what was happening, but as Joe, my dentist, said, “This is not good.”

After my teeth were addressed, I walked from my dentist’s at 40th Street through groups of my fellow New Yorkers, stunned and crying. I walked all the way downtown to where I worked, at Hudson and Franklin, one of a very small number of people moving against the tide of grim thousands who were coming north, covered in white soot, still carrying their briefcases.

Reason number 3: Men, especially men in power, love war. There are times during which it seems all men can do is make all those war noises and do speeches and command the troops. Time to remind everyone that no one in New York City, as profoundly affected as we were, called for all-out war as a response to our catastrophe. Maybe because we New Yorkers read the brilliant reporting in the New York Times which presented concise biographical histories of each fanatic who committed that act of mass murder and suicide. They were, each of them, clinically insane. The Bush reaction to this crazy small gang of terrorists was…what’s the expression for it? Out of proportion? A cloak of smoke to cover up his real failure at stopping the attack?

As a New Yorker, I was thinking of a more targeted, fine-tuned, artful and intelligent  response against a small terrorist cabal. Because we are supposedly an intelligent civilization, which happens to have all those teams of elite special forces. But then I didn’t vote for Bush. And I’m a female and do not understand war.

So there we were, establishing a war in Afghanistan. For what purpose? Making Nicolle Wallace’s boss a, gulp, War Time President! And we know that’s the goal of far too many presidents: having a war of one’s very own. Being CinC beats actually having to do a real day’s work for the American people.

The people yammering on MSNBC seemed to have forgotten how this rotten thing happened, and who promoted it. So it’s both ignorant and knee-jerk to blame Joe Biden for pulling us out. Especially since it was the loathsome former guy who “negotiated” — or whatever he called it — our departure.

Katty Kay. Who the fuck is this remarkably off-putting bleached blond with a Brit accent who spent her time on Nicolle’s show advising us crisply that the United States has lost all sorts of credibility, lost allies, lost…face, I guess she’s saying, by pulling out of a twenty-year war. Katty, bless her, is focusing on what a disaster our pull-out is for Afghanistani women and girls. To whom, she says, we promised so much and now we are abandoning them.

Oh, Katty Kay. Yeah, Katty, that’s precisely why we engaged in this dreadful failure of a war. We didn’t send our mighty troops (along with our allies’ mighty troops) to Afghanistan in pointless overkill against a tiny group of religious fanatics who lived some of the time in remote caves, led by a paranoid schizophrenic. Oh no. We shipped troops and weaponry to a primitive misogynistic theocracy in order to…rescue the Afghan women! And how disgraceful it is that we’re withdrawing from that promised purpose!

Another purpose seems to have been to attack Afghanistan in order to instruct by example an Afghan army that could learn, by fighting us, how to do what armies are supposed to do: protect a country against attack. That is, an army that could guarantee we would never again be able to invade Afghanistan. We spent a lot of money on that purpose. Doesn’t seem to have worked.

I’ve had it. Yes, I agree with the U.S. generals. It’s heartbreaking to see what’s happening in Afghanistan. Which is, in essence, a retreat to its former primeval state before we waged a war for the overweening purpose of introducing the Afghans to the 20th century. Or 21st century.

But it was heartbreaking and dumb to wage war on a fragmented country when a very small group of non-Afghans, taking refuge in that country, decided to fly our planes into my city.

If you generals had thought this through twenty years ago and discouraged Bush from a massive invasion in favor of the sort of sharp, targeted operation, based on good intelligence, that found Bin Laden — remember him? — you wouldn’t have to be so heartbroken now.

By the way, Nicolle, don’t ask generals about the strategy of getting out of a war. They do not know how to get out of war. They only know how to wage it when told to do so.

As for Katty Kay, oh shut the fuck up.

 

Posted in Joe Biden and his people, Politics, The Facts of Life, War on women | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on War. I don’t get it. But then I’m a naive and foolish woman

What will the DOJ do about Trump?

The public agitation for confronting the Trump Problem is now reaching the upper echelon of great lawyers. And I pay attention to them.

Since the last election, there has been a loud public drumbeat for immediate indictment and conviction on a Greek diner menu list of Trump’s offenses, criminal and civil. Some people are so out of breath with the screaming, they’ve collapsed into expressing cynicism about whether he will ever be brought to justice for the horror he inflicted upon us.

I am calmly confident that he will.

People who are most infuriated are not lawyers and lack one major quality any lawyer must have: patience. Building an evidence-heavy case addressing a web of criminality and a long list of spiders to be interrogated takes a very long time. Given the level and layers of Trump’s offenses against this country, and that it’s an entirely new world in law and governance — prosecuting a former president has never been done before — can you imagine how scrupulously extra-careful all prosecuting authorities are being?

And now lawyers themselves are laying down their own insistence that DOJ investigate Trump and prosecute him if the facts and evidence are manifest. The best of them advise patience because this is a huge legal deal and takes a long time.

I think about this a lot. Here’s what I’m thinking:

There’s no reason to believe the DOJ has not already begun investigating Trump, et al. Didn’t I learn during the Comey uproar that such investigations are (almost) always done without public announcements? The Mueller investigation did not leak once, if I recall.

We should all remember that Merrick Garland has been Attorney General for only five full months. Aside from dealing with the Trump Problem, among the major jobs for him and his deputies are reviewing every document produced by Trump’s DOJ, which was truly Trump‘s DOJ, not the American people’s. I assume there were a lot of time bombs left behind when Trump’s minions cleared out. That job presses, because there are statutes of limitations and court schedules that must be met.

And speaking of Trump’s minions, that’s another job for the DOJ — clearing them out.

So the DOJ is busy busy busy.

I’ve recently thought of another reason for the DOJ to be super-extra cautious about investigating and indicting Trump. They must, simultaneously and surreptitiously, evaluate the crazy (and armed) MAGA mob around the country, to determine what sort of response they might have to an announcement their god is going to be prosecuted.

Not that the DOJ should, or will, be afraid to go after Trump. But I suspect the agency is deeply aware of the need to have the country and its law enforcement agencies better prepared to confront any violent protests than they were on January 6.

 

Posted in Fascism, Joe Biden and his people, Law, suits and order, Lawyers, Politics, The Facts of Life, Trumpism | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on What will the DOJ do about Trump?

Do TV commercials for drugs irritate you?

Well, I’m here to help.

From what I’m hearing, Prevagen should get the Clio for the most irritating ads on TV*. Let us cheer! Yay, Prevagen! What an advertising achievement! You make us growl.

Since I am immune from catching the Oh I Have To Buy This Miracle Stuff! TV ad virus, I’m the perfect person to do some digging around.

With a big assist from my friend Yola, here is what I’ve learned about Prevagen.

I recalled the initial Prevagen ads claimed the product was derived from some wondrous stuff found in certain jellyfish, stuff that enhanced our brain functioning, specifically our memory. Prevagen is not running those ads anymore. Why not?

Because those claims caused a class action lawsuit, which Prevagen had to settle for a ton of money.

And then the FDA stepped in, because Prevagen’s claim about that jellyfish stuff wasn’t quite accurate. The company producing Prevagen does not, it turns out, harvest jellyfish for their apoaequorin (a/k/a jellyfish stuff). Instead, they make a lab version of it which makes Prevagen not a supplement, but a drug.

Oh. And their claims of no side effects are false (my bolding):

In a warning letter, the FDA accused the company of not reporting to the government “adverse events like seizures, strokes, and worsening symptoms of multiple sclerosis that had been reported to your firm as being associated with the use of Prevagen products.” Reports about the supplement to the company have also included chest pain, tremors, fainting and other serious symptoms, the FDA says.

So why is Prevagen still on the market — at a pretty hefty cost? At Duane Reade, the packages are locked up behind a glass door which, like a bank vault, can be opened only by request.

Well, Prevagen changed its TV ad claims. Indeed, it doesn’t claim anything for itself. It corralled some older users who tell us that their memories had been improved by taken Prevagen. And that people around them have noticed how sharp their memories are. “‘You’ve got the memory of an elephant!'” one guy reports people have told him.

If you listen carefully to these testaments, you can easily pick them apart. How can someone claim Prevagen has worked for eight years? What’s the basis of comparison?

It’s all absurd.

So what should we all be taking to enhance our memories? Before I looked at Prevagen itself, I found a report on “brain vitamins” on WebMD. If you are wild to believe that something will help you think better, or remember an actor you saw once in a TV show thirty years ago, or will ward off Alzheimer’s, hey, read the report. Depending on your level of desperation, you might find something in there.

I, for one, will continue to drink coffee and cook with turmeric (also known as poor man’s saffron). And eat nuts, grains, greens, fish and yadda yadda yadda.

*There is no such Clio. Drat.

 

Posted in Law, suits and order, The Facts of Life, TV commercials | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on Do TV commercials for drugs irritate you?