Turning factoids into facts: Mars, Hitler and history

Let’s All Go to Mars!

So many MAGAts, including the MAGAt King, have been heralding our imminent landing and community-building on Mars, presumably via one of Elon Musk’s rockets. Another presumption: it is one which isn’t prone to shattering mid-air over Texas.

There’s another wee Martian problem, though. I’m sure Musk isn’t aware of it, although the facts are available, but he’s so busy bulling around in our government fine china shop, he’s not had time to pay attention to outer space.

Thing is, the two-year space voyage to get to Mars would expose astronauts to Galactic Cosmic Radiation, which would badly affect their kidneys. In short, GCR would cause kidney failure. (And erectile dysfunction but I think if their kidneys go while they’re up in space, well, hey, erections would shrivel in importance.)

I’m posting this as a public service announcement for astronauts who might consider being employed for the Mars trip, since it doesn’t look like Elon will be available to discuss kidney failure with them before take-off.

BTW, given this information, do you have a list of people you’d like to see on that Mars space trip? Along with Elon?

Hitler Was Not Elected

There’s a commonly accepted but factually inaccurate idea that Hitler was elected by the German people. He wasn’t. Here’s what actually happened:

In 1932 there was a succession of elections in Germany, due to a mind-boggling number of political parties who were running for seats in the Reichstag. In the penultimate election of that year, the Nazi Party won slightly more than a third of the seats; the Communist Party won slightly less than a third. Obviously, neither had a majority.

Under the circumstances, it was an irrational hope that the Nazis and the Communists would form a governing coalition because, without one, nothing was going to get done. Surprise! The Nazis and the Communists did not form a governing coalition.

So there was another election in November, 1932 (which turned out to be the last election in Germany until after World War II). The Nazis actually lost some seats, a serious disappointment, while the Communists gained some.

The presidency of Germany was an elected position, and a powerful one. Paul von Hindenburg (the man, who died in 1934, not the blimp which died in 1937) had been president on and off for quite a while. During the penultimate election, he had beaten Adolph Hitler.

The political situation was unstable (seventeen+ political parties who ran for and won seats in the Reichstag will do that to a state). Hindenburg was old, cranky and under a lot of pressure. Since the chancellorship was an appointed, not an elected, position, Hindenberg was tasked with naming someone.

The chancellorship was a fairly weak office. Hindenburg was a moderate. His cabinet (with nary a Nazi) was moderate. Along with a lot of other groups, he did not like Hitler. But he named him as chancellor.

Hitler did not win an election, nor did his party ever win a majority.

Does History Repeat Itself?

I have never fully understood the warning about history repeating itself, whether in the omnipresent George Santayana quote — “Those who cannot remember the past, are condemned to repeat it” — or any other Big Statement of Great Profundity. But I’m not a fan of philosophers or the product of their thinking.

I am, however, a fan of history and the people who write about it. I’ve been having a life-altering experience reading a book I found in my bookshelves. Naturally, I thought it was from a college course in world history but have discovered it must have been someone else’s book, that I’d never read it before, and had no idea why it was in my bookshelves.

It is A History Of The Modern World, Third Edition (it’s currently up to twelve editions). Published in 1965, it was written by R.R. Palmer, from Washington U. in St. Louis, and Joel Colton, of Duke University.

Reading it feels like floating in space (not in a Musk rocket) above the blue planet Earth, and as the world revolves, the entire history of humankind and the changing shapes of the continents and oceans appear to me. I can zoom in and back out, like Google Earth, but not static. (I think I’m living in a tesseract.)

I’ve seen small and large wars — by far, the most repeated events in history — and borders that expand and contract, usually as a result of those wars. (That was a fairly boring, very long period of history.)

Things picked up as individuals with endless curiosity emerged to use their brains to explore the nature of life, to develop and test theories, and to create bodies of knowledge. A great relief from wars, and the perpetual shifting borders of states (especially Poland, for which I’ve developed some sympathy).

Over the millennia of human history, I began to recognize the vast capabilities of human beings: creation and destruction and re-creation. Visions of a future ideal, especially that. I began to see how voiceless human mass separated into individual voices, and began to hear what they were asking and then demanding.

Advances and retreats. And advances.

It’s not that what we’re living through now is a repeat of the past, although it has that superficial coloration. But on the infinite scale of human history, it’s the sort of disorder that has appeared before — and has returned to order quite rapidly.

Human beings crave order. The few chaotic sorts who mess around with our order are short-lived. The only semi-permanent structure they create is the bunker into which they will disappear when we become angry enough and don’t want to see them any more.

Gee, I didn’t mean to write all that. What I did mean to tell you is my reading of this masterful history has elevated me and given me a certain calm. And the occasional bursts of lyricism throughout it have been infectious.

Perhaps the losses [of life caused by World War II] came to thirty-five or forty million, but at such figures the human mind retreats and human sensitivities are dulled. It is enough to say that peace had come.

Took my breath away…”at such figures the human mind retreats and human sensitivities are dulled. It is enough to say that peace had come.”

Oh, and about history repeating itself, this, from an assessment of the state of the world in 1940:

History seemed to repeat itself, in the distant and unreal way which is the only way in which it ever repeats.

 

 

 

 

Posted in Culture, Fascism, Government, Human rights, Immigration, The Facts of Life | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Turning factoids into facts: Mars, Hitler and history

Very likely a satire

Yet another pointed comment directed at the selfish, the foolish, and the wicked. That is, the mob occupying D.C. at the moment.

The hidden and awful Wisdom which apportions the destinies of mankind is pleased so to humiliate and cast down the tender, good, and wise; and to set up the selfish, the foolish, or the wicked. O be humble, my brother, in your properity! Be gentle with those who are less lucky, if not more deserving. Think, what right have you to be scornful, whose virtue is a deficiency of temptation, whose success may be a change, whose rank may be an ancestor’s accident, whose prosperity is very likely a satire.

The mockingly gentle mockery is by William Makepeace Thackeray. I landed upon it somewhere near the end of his great, great Vanity Fair.

Posted in Culture, The Facts of Life, The filthy rich, Trumpism | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Very likely a satire

Paul Krugman’s departure left a huge hole in the NYT

Fortunately for those of us who have a slippery grasp of worldwide economics but know it’s important to understand it, Paul Krugman is now publishing what he wants to say, how he wants to say it and when he wants to say it on Substack. You can sign up for different versions; a yearly subscription is $70 but I selected a starter version: some free essays in my e-mailbox, which arrive virtually every day.

Good thing because…tariffs? Geez did I need Krugman to verify my inner sense that they are stupid and crazy.

I’ve pulled some choice selections from Krugman’s exegesis on these things called tariffs (the title is “The End of America”) just in case you’ve got a hole in your heart where Paul Krugman’s Times columns used to be. I don’t think he’ll mind. (I’ve bolded a couple of things that are Pure Krugman — everything I love him for, aside from his unique gift at explaining inexplicable things to me.)

∈

I’ve been saying for a while that markets were far too complacent about Trump’s threat to impose tariffs on Canada and Mexico, believing that he wouldn’t follow through because it’s such a stupid, self-destructive idea.

But yeah, Trump did the stupid thing. Here’s an excerpt from Krugman’s excerpt of the NYT report from the White House’s new, very blonde and expectedly feeble press secretary:

Ms. Leavitt said the president had chosen to impose tariffs because the three countries “have all enabled illegal drugs to pour into America.”

“The amount of fentanyl that has been seized at the southern border in the last few years alone has the potential to kill tens of millions of Americans,” she said. “And so the president is intent on doing this.”

Back to Krugman:

I think you have to see “fentanyl” in this context as the equivalent of “weapons of mass destruction” in the runup to the invasion of Iraq. It’s not the real reason; Canada isn’t even a major source of fentanyl. It’s just a plausible-sounding reason for a president to do what he wanted to do for other reasons — George W. Bush wanted a splendid little war, Donald Trump just wants to impose tariffs and assert dominance.

Also, although I’m not sure such things matter anymore, what’s the legal basis for these tariffs? U.S. trade law gives the president huge discretion to impose tariffs, but only for a specific set of reasons: economic injury from import surges (Section 201), national security (Section 232), unfair foreign competition (Section 301), dumping — sales below costs. Drug smuggling, especially imaginary drug smuggling, isn’t on the list.

The president can impose tariffs much more broadly if he declares a national economic emergency. But has he done that? Does 2.6 percent inflation and 4.1 percent unemployment sound like an economic emergency to you? And even if Trump gets around to declaring an economic emergency, what does fentanyl have to do with it?

As far as I can tell, there’s a real possibility that Trump’s new tariffs will face a court challenge, and that he will lose. I’m not an expert on trade law, but I do know a bit, and this looks flatly illegal to me.

But even if these tariffs are blocked, or Trump finds some way to declare victory and call them off, the damage will be immense.

As I wrote the other day, in the three decades since NAFTA went into effect, North American manufacturing has evolved into a highly integrated system whose products — autos in particular, but manufactured goods more broadly — typically contain components from all three members of the pact, which may be shipped across the borders multiple times. Manufacturers developed this system not just because tariffs were low or zero, but because they thought they had a guarantee that tariffs would stay low.

One way of saying this is that until just the other day there was really no such thing as U.S. manufacturing, Canadian manufacturing or Mexican manufacturing, just North American manufacturing — a highly efficient, mutually beneficial system that sprawled across the three nations’ borders.

But now we have a U.S. president saying that a duly negotiated and signed trade pact isn’t worth the paper it was printed on — that he can impose high tariffs on the other signatories whenever he feels like it. And even if the tariffs go away, the private sector will know that they can always come back; the credibility of this trade agreement, or any future trade agreement, will be lost. So North American manufacturing will disintegrate — that is, dis-integrate — reverting to inefficient, fragmented national industries.

Hence my title, “The end of North America.”

And to think that many people imagined that Trump would be good for business.

Well, gee. I seem to have “excerpted” and bolded quite a lot. Do me a favor and sign up for his newsletter so I don’t have to do this again.

Posted in Capitalism, Fascism, Government, Journalism, Judiciary, MAGA, Politics, Propaganda, The Facts of Life, Trumpism | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Paul Krugman’s departure left a huge hole in the NYT