Some fierce and positive thoughts

I’m thinking we’ve been dragged into a new Civil War — dragged, quite appropriately, by white supremacists, male and female, whose need to express their endless hatred for women and black women got them to Trump.

Their cause is as amoral, ahistorical and rotten as it ever has been. Their leaders are much lower in, uh, quality than Jefferson Davis and Robert E. Lee. (Who, I’m sure you realize, lost that Civil War.) Trump, his voters and his oncoming administration are nuts, dumb and incompetent.

◊

I’ve been picking up some sane thinking about our situation. New York’s Attorney General, Tish James, gave a sober, quiet and fierce speech about the election, which brought home to me how we the people will function in the next few years.

  • Our Democratic states will in effect become our government. The twenty-three Democratic Party governors are not mild-mannered wimps; they will do what they have practice in doing — coalescing into a single-minded unit to provide us with our governmental needs — those the Trump government has bragged it will deprive us of.
  • Our Democratic Attorneys General will continue their alliance — the one which made friends and allies of once-AG Kamala Harris and once-AG Josh Shapiro and other AGs — but now, as Tish James said, will have meat to grind in opposition to the Trump administration and will in no way shrink from the opposition. The Democratic AGs will in effect become a collective Department of Justice. The federal DOJ looks to be peopled with the sort of nutty, out of the woodwork mediocrities Trump needs in order to convince himself he’s the brightest guy in the room. Each of these AGs is so much smarter than Trump’s entire mob.

I intend to live fully in my state, the State of New York.

◊

Every day I get some stuff from the Atlantic and today I came upon Tom Nichols in my email. On this weird, awful, infuriating day, after reading a whole heap of grief and dire predictions on TAFKAT, Nichols’s essay came as a bracing sea breeze on my face. Some of his thoughts:

An aspiring fascist is the president-elect, again, of the United States. This is our political reality: Donald Trump is going to bring a claque of opportunists and kooks (led by the vice president–elect, a person who once compared Trump to Hitler) into government this winter, and even if senescence overtakes the president-elect, Trump’s minions will continue his assault on democracy, the rule of law, and the Constitution.

The urge to cast blame will be overwhelming, because there is so much of it to go around. When the history of this dark moment is written, those responsible will include not only Trump voters but also easily gulled Americans who didn’t vote or who voted for independent or third-party candidates because of their own selfish peeves.

Trump’s opponents will also blame Russia and other malign powers. Without a doubt, America’s enemies—some of whom dearly hoped for a Trump win—made efforts to flood the public square with propaganda. According to federal and state government reports, several bomb threats that appeared to originate from Russian email domains were aimed at areas with minority voters. But as always, the power to stop Trump rested with American voters at the ballot box, and blaming others is a pointless exercise.

So now what?

The first order of business is to redouble every effort to preserve American democracy. If I may invoke Winston Churchill, this is not the end or the beginning of the end; it is the end of the beginning.

For a decade, Trump has been trying to destroy America’s constitutional order. His election in 2016 was something like a prank gone very wrong, and he likely never expected to win. But once in office, he and his administration became a rocket sled of corruption, chaos, and sedition. Trump’s lawlessness finally caught up with him after he was forced from office by the electorate. He knew that his only hope was to return to the presidency and destroy the last instruments of accountability.

Paradoxically, however, Trump’s reckless venality is a reason for hope. Trump has the soul of a fascist but the mind of a disordered child. He will likely be surrounded by terrible but incompetent people. All of them can be beaten: in court, in Congress, in statehouses around the nation, and in the public arena. America is a federal republic, and the states—at least those in the union that will still care about democracy—have ways to protect their citizens from a rogue president. Nothing is inevitable, and democracy will not fall overnight.

“Trump has the soul of a fascist but the mind of a disordered child. He will likely be surrounded by terrible but incompetent people.” Reminds me of a brilliant phrase from my cousin Ben Wittes when he evaluated Trump’s early presidency: “Malevolence tempered by incompetence.”

The malevolence has gotten much worse — but so has the incompetence.

These are not dark thoughts.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in Corruption, Fascism, Government, Journalism, Politics, Propaganda, Racism, The Facts of Life, Trumpism, voting and voting rights, War | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Some fierce and positive thoughts

So how is this optimist reacting to the nightmarish surreality?

It’s 5:30 pm. I haven’t changed from my sleep gear, not yet. Maybe I won’t, not today. I just realized I haven’t brushed my teeth. Or eaten anything.

What have I been doing? Reading a lot of despair, rage, knee-jerk blaming and flailing, incredulity — and arguing with certain aspects of it, even while I’m shattered, furious and seeing everything through a disorted lens. Somebody wrote somewhere that it’s as if a psychiatric institution flung open its doors and let the inmates out to vote, and to delude themselves into thinking they are competent to run a massive government.

I listened to Kamala’s inspiring concession speech. She has become my ideal politician: intelligent, wise, relaxed, pointed with her criticism and specific in laying out the sort of federal government I’ve always believed in and supported. I genuinely love her. She will not be disappearing.

In 2016, it was awfully clear to us women that misogyny affected the presidential race. In 2024, I believed we’d gotten past that. That’s clearly my optimism for you. Now, we have to add racism to the same fucking misogyny.

8:32 pm. Still in my PJs, ate some popcorn and V8 juice.

 

Posted in Fascism, Jan 6, Kamala, political campaigns, Politics, Pro choice, Racism, The Facts of Life, Trumpism, voting and voting rights | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Why did this happen? It’s kind of simple

For years I’ve been reading those much-mocked New York Times diner interviews with voters. I read how those people respond to a reporter’s questions. And every single time I said out loud, “These people are just stupid.” By that I meant ignorant about government, about reality, about causation, and about time, i.e., how long it takes for a government to get things done in a country of 360 million people.

They were just flat out dumb. And flat out incurious. Yet they seemed to feel rather smug about their opinions and beliefs, and quite taken with the serious attention being shown to them by a newspaper they clearly didn’t read. They sort of preened.

I’m not entirely sure why I was expected to pay attention to them, or why I should be caring about their situations in life. My compassion is for vulnerable people, not people who are pissed that they’re being overlooked. Flown over. Most of the diner bunch were employed or self-employed at solid jobs, in solid professions. Some were university students.

But their resentment of me — as an avatar of what they seemed to loathe — leaked out of all those Times pages. They all seemed to live in another country, a weird sort of country. A science fiction sort of country. I kept thinking this was The Invasion of the Body Snatchers. Oh, and The Stepford Wives. Yeah. Definitely.

Today the Times had one of their sober, deep analyses of what happened. A lot of readers chimed in with comments. A lot of blaming tossed around, in all sorts of directions. The Times and its readers came up with reasons this happened: voters were distressed about immigration, the economy, their wages. That’s why they voted for Trump. One reader said they voted for a return to sanity and economic growth. (!?!?!?)

What nonsense. All of it. I understand why the Times has to write analyses of difficult situations, why they are compelled to explain how something so awfully extraordinary came about. The problem is, the Times is full of intelligent and rational journalists. Intelligent and rational people are incapable of explaining craziness; they are helpless to do anything but lay out their search for rationality in these thoughtful, misguided articles. Their work at being profound is utterly wasted and sad.

Why a majority voted for Trump has nothing to do with the Times’ interpretation, which is, I think, based on their years’ worth of diner interviews and the things that the diners said about what worries them and how they feel.

The Diner Mob mouths “immigration” — although there’s no indication they have been affected by immigration, let alone have understood how much our country, their territory and our tax system depend upon undocumented immigrants; there was a strong immigration bill which Trump killed. Their anger at immigration is crap and someone fed it to them

The Diner Mob mouths “inflation” — for which there is no basis in reality without considering COVID, supply chains, corporate price gouging, blah blah blah. They’re mouthing blame because someone fed them that crap.

The diners mouth “the economy.” There’s no indication that any of them understands anything whatsoever about “the economy.” Someone fed them that crap.

If Trump voters were ever capable of investigating their own viscera, their own psyches, their explanation would be quite different. It’d be a scary confession.

Here’s what David Fiedler in Poughkeepsie, New York wrote as a comment to that New York Times analysis. It’s so smart and sane and wise, I’m blowing it up:

I think this article makes the whole thing too complicated. They voted for him because they LIKE the venom he spews, not in spite of it. His embrace of hatred gives them permission to hate openly. It’s really very simple.

Add in white supremacy, racism and misogyny and it’s still very simple, Mr. Fiedler.

Aside from his many, many pathologies, Trump is at base a stupid man. He talks hate, resentment, persecution. He talks vengeance, violence, sexual assault. He is incoherent when he talks about anything other than hating. It is at the center of his existence. It’s really all he is. He is a stupid man who hates.

The Diner Mob is undoubtedly smarter than Trump. Almost anyone is. But they seem to feel they’ve been cheated by life, they haven’t gotten the gilt Trump flashes, haven’t been hugely successful, even if Trump’s success is one of his many lies.

The Diner Mob has taken Trump’s sick hate as a release from acceptable human behavior and the controls we as adults accept that restrict us from saying and doing horrible things to each other. Because if they imitate his resentment and hate, maybe it’ll somehow hand them the attention and money and power they think they deserve.

That’s what they voted for, those Diner People. They voted to join Trump in stupidity, in open and naked rage. He licensed their ids to fly free. That’s why they voted for him.

Somehow, I don’t feel obligated to hold them in new respect and admiration just because they’ve shown how much they hate the rest of us.

Do you?

 

Posted in Capitalism, COVID-19, Fascism, Government, Human rights, Kamala, Politics, Propaganda, Racism, The Facts of Life, Trumpism, voting and voting rights, War on women | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Why did this happen? It’s kind of simple