Whew! Last and key U.S. and Hitler’s Germany comparison

In some ways, the military is the most important consideration when you’re wondering whether a country is primed for a dictator or resistant to one. So…

The Military

–United States 2024

A few months ago, my brother and I were having lunch with some friends who expressed worry that Trump could take over the United States the way Hitler took over Germany. My brother said, “Not going to happen,” and when the question, “Why not?” was posed, both of us at the same time said, “The Army.”

A tyrant needs to have the country’s military behind him. Rather in/famously, Trump does not have our military anywhere near him: “My generals” have sharply reminded us that soldiers swear an oath to our Constitution, not to a monarch. Nor to an elected C-in-C.

Trump never had “his” generals. They were always our country’s generals.

–Weimar Republic 1930

High-ranking officers, numbers of whom were of the Germany nobility — for whom having at least one son in the military was a traditional source of pride — paid little attention to Hitler until the 1930’s. By and large, military officers were monarchists, not democrats or communists.

The Versailles Treaty, which mandated a painful reduction to the Germany military,  enraged the officer corps. After that, William Shirer writes, “…the Army, small at it was in numbers, became a state within a state, exerting an increasing influence on the nation’s foreign and domestic policies until a point was reached where the Republic’s continued existence depended on the will of the officer corps.”

Shirer reports a striking incident from 1923 when Bavaria was making noises of secession. The Reichstag’s then-President Ebert hastily summoned his cabinet and invited “the monocled, poker-faced Prussian Commander in Chief” General von Seeckt to attend.

“Ebert wanted to know where the Army stood. Seeckt bluntly told him. ‘The Army, Mr. President, stands behind me.‘”

So, in effect the German military was a forceful political party in itself. Only after Hitler’s Nazi Party won a majority in the Reichstag did the officer class reluctantly accept Hitler; they came to understand many of the underclass soldiers were eager Nazis.

Of the many (over 40) attempts at assassinating Hitler, the most serious were led by German military officers. And the Abwehr, the military intelligence agency, had a dual personality attitude to Hitler. The Abwehr leader, Admiral Wilhelm Canaris, operated surreptitiously, personally handing classified information to the Allies. Some of his agents acted to subvert the Reich, even while the body of the Abwehr did its job, collecting intelligence for the Wehrmacht. (It’s a terrific, if strenuously complex, spy and double-agent story.)

Hitler had quite a number of his military leaders executed. Canaris was one of them.

 

That’s it, that’s all I’ve got under the general heading “Why the contemporary United States is not now and never has been anything like Hitler’s Germany.”

 

Posted in Fascism, political campaigns, Politics, The Facts of Life, Trumpism, War | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Whew! Last and key U.S. and Hitler’s Germany comparison

Is the atmosphere in the US right now like that in 1930’s Germany?

It’s generally understood that a country is not vulnerable to a dictatorial take-over if  its domestic, economic and political climate(s) are in good shape. So I’ve done a bit of research to make a comparison between the United States a few days before our election and the Weimar Republic shortly before Hitler came to full power.

I’ve broken down specific aspects of each country’s landscape into the categories aspiring tyrants use in their demagoguery; by pounding relentlessly on problems in these areas, a demagogue tells the citizenry that things are “garbage,” but if he’s elected, he’ll clean it all up.

So are we garbage? And was Germany in 1930?

Economy

–United States 2024

  • Population: Between 336 million and 345 million
  • U.S. economy grew at an annualized rate of 3% in the second quarter of 2024, higher than the revised 1.6% expansion in the first quarter.
  • Inflation decreased from 7 in 2021 to 2.2 in 2024.
  • Unemployment rate, 4.1, a decrease from 4.2% in August 2024.
  • Wage increase: Total wages and salaries in the US increased by 28.01% from November 2020 to August 2024.

–Weimar Republic 1930

  • Population: Approximately 64,294,000
  • The Great Depression – serious economic crisis. How serious? ⇓
  • Unemployment: Skyrocketed. The number of people in full-time employment fell from twenty million in 1929 to just over eleven million in 1933.
  • Business closures: Over 10,000 businesses closing every year.
  • Wage decline: Wages fell by 39% from 1929 to 1932.
  • Poverty: Sharp increase in poverty levels across the country.
  • Worthless money: The German mark became essentially worthless. By November 1923, one U.S. dollar was equivalent to 1,000 billion (a trillion) marks.
  • Constant price increases: Prices of goods doubled within a month.
  • Wage depreciation: Salaries became worthless almost immediately after being paid.

Crime

–United States 2024

January through June 2023 and 2024 indicates reported violent crime decreased by 10.3%. Murder decreased by 22.7%, rape decreased by 17.7%, robbery decreased by 13.6%, and aggravated assault decreased by 8.1%. (And U.S.-born citizens are over 2 times more likely to be arrested for violent crimes compared to undocumented immigrants.)

–Weimar Republic 1930

  • Crime rates surged after the 1929 Great Depression; criminal gangs became active in various illegal activities, including prostitution, narcotics, gambling, and robbery.
  • Paramilitary groups associated with the Nazis and Communists. Violent streets clashes and fatalities resulting from political street battles.
  • Political assassinations and extrajudicial killings also became common.

Immigration

–United States 2024

  • Approximately 11 million undocumented immigrants as of 2022.
  • Undocumented immigrants paid nearly $100 billion in federal, state and local tax revenue in 2022.
  • Undocumented immigrants paid higher tax rates than the top 1% of income earners in 40 states.

–Weimar Republic 1930

No evidence of serious immigration to Germany because of disasterous economy, around 33% unemployment and political instability. Any measurable migration was out of Germany, not in.

The “Other,” i.e., the “Enemy Within”

United States 2024

“Others” have to be recognizably distinct in appearance to hostile, racist whites with Nazi-like intentions. These Americans (and their numbers) are:

  • Black — 47.9 million.
  • Latino (Hispanic) — 65 million.
  • Asian — Approximately 19.7 million to 23.5 million.
  • Native Americans — Over 9.7 million.
  • Orthodox Jews — roughly 900,000.

That’s 146 million people in a total population of 336 million, i.e., 43.4% of our population. These “others” are well represented on our voting rolls and in our government, police forces and the military. That is, they are not “others”; they are us.

Weimar Republic 1930

  • Jews — approximately 505,000-525,000.
  • Roma — educated guess, 30,000 to 100,000.
  • Homosexuals — Exact population numbers are not available, but the scope of the community is suggested by 170 clubs, bars and pubs catering to gays and lesbians in Berlin. Between 1933-1945, an estimated 100,000 men were arrested for homosexuality across Germany.

At maximum, that’s a total of 725,000 fairly identifiable “others” out of a total population of over 64 million. That is around 1.2% of the population.

 

As I re-read this just now, I see clearly that Trump, et MAGA al., are running for election not in the United States today but in 1930’s Germany.

It’s as if the entire MAGA crowd has lapsed into a 94-year time warp, chosen to live in mass amnesia rather than live in substantially good and promising contemporary reality.

It’s weirder and weirder and weirder and weirder…

Posted in Crime & Punishment, Government, Joe Biden and his people, Politics, The Facts of Life | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Is the atmosphere in the US right now like that in 1930’s Germany?

“Why are lies called falsehoods now?”

That’s part of a reader’s comment on a New York Times story about a nutty conspiracy theory that wrecked a professional conference in Atlanta, Georgia.

I can answer the question, which has been at the forefront of attacks on journalism for quite a few years — another effect of Trump’s malevolent presence in our lives.

The word “lie” incorporates in its definition consciousness of the falsehood in the statement. If a journalist, say, calls someone a liar, he/she is stating that the liar is aware that he is lying, is conscious of producing false information.

A “falsehood” is an a-factual statement by someone who may be ignorant of the facts, repeating something he or she has heard, or is deluded in some way. “Falsehood” is the proper word to use if a journalist has no proof that the person making the statement knows that the statement is a lie.

It’s tricky, yeah, but “falsehood” protects journalists from endless, mindless defamation lawsuits.* Aside from that, it’s an accurate word which does not negate an intrinsic probability that the falsehood is indeed a lie.

It’s not even a subtle distinction. As a reader I’m aware of it and I’ll bet you are, too. We readers are mentally and fearlessly allowed to assign the word “lie” to the stuff coming out of MAGA mouths.

So I suggest the antagonism to the vocabulary of journalists is misplaced. If you are desperate to have public figures labeled as liars, plenty of credible critics social media use that word — usually during their rants against print journalists who don’t.

*Without getting into the libel lawsuit Lillian Hellman filed against Mary McCarthy.

Posted in Journalism, Propaganda, The Facts of Life, Trumpism | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on “Why are lies called falsehoods now?”