What is the truth about the war? About any war?

My heart bleeds; my head stays calm.

That’s the best I can do with reports from this war when the news media is spilling over with information. I react with horror — impartial horror — and then I wonder what of this massive information is factual, and what is not.

War is an event which demands we take sides. But in our age of communications, when every movement, every death and every passionate conviction feed our minds almost instantly, taking a single side and not moving from that side is emotionally and intellectually fraught.

One thing only is true: no matter what violent action kicked it off, war is a chaotic monstrosity. The real facts can only be collected in the aftermath, the long aftermath.

The most significant, honorable and moving statement about this war was written by the New Yorker’s editor, David Remnick, in his superlative report from Israel in the November 6, 2023 issue. Its title is “In The Cities Of Killing: The Hamas massacre, the air strikes in Gaza, and what comes after.”

The first sentence stuns me. It is…

The only way to tell this story is to try to tell it truthfully and to know that you will fail.

Ω

Probably because I was born during World War II, I’ve been reading histories of it throughout my life. But only when I recently read Richard Overy’s Blood and Ruins did I learn immutable truths about war. They are:

War is a catastrophic mess, unmitigated chaos, the suspension of human order.

War is both itself an atrocity and an action releasing all atrocities of which man is capable.

The periodic need to make war is a glitch in the psyches of men.

The men who make wars, who command the actions, do not fight the wars and rarely get killed by the wars.

The strategic geniuses of war fuck up consistently. The only way any of them will eventually be designated as heroic is by burying some truth in the muck.

A powerful part of war is propaganda, promulgated by each side to elicit the population’s support and to build a fighting force. Any contemporaneous reportage of a war is unavoidably infected with propaganda.

The only soaring finality to any war is Overy’s title — blood and ruins. The ruins can be cleared for new construction; the blood can’t.

The full, accurate story about this war will not be in today’s media, no matter how scrupulous reporters are in attempting to gather and communicate complex information.

It’s not the fault of media; it’s the fault of war.

So when I read or listen to reports about this war, I try to hold my emotional reactions in abeyance because I don’t know what is entirely accurate. Thus, I’m deeply grateful to David Remnick for writing, “The only way to tell this story is to try to tell it truthfully and to know that you will fail.”

 

 

 

 

Posted in Propaganda, The Facts of Life, War | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on What is the truth about the war? About any war?

Last week I voted. What happened?

Well, nothing. Except I voted.

I have a feeling I’ve said much of this previously but it’s important so here I am, saying it again. Because I spend some time on Twitter (I don’t care what that crazy man calls it) seeing the novel attempts either to suppress voting or to make it so effortful it might cause people to give up voting.

Here I am in a very large city going over to my polling place for early voting. It’s a large utilitarian space in a public school. I enter. There are a few steps down to a level where sits a friendly polling place guy who warns me to hold onto the banister. To please him, I hold onto the banister.

I enter The Voting Room. It is very big. Scattered over the floor are (a) tables where one registers and gets the ballot; (b) those funky little portable writing surfaces surrounded by privacy walls, where one will fill out the ballot; (c) scanners; (d) smiling polling people who know where I should go; and (e) one uniformed policeman who sits quietly in a corner.

I go to a table. The lady behind the table asks for my last name. I tell her. She types on a keyboard and even before I can spill out my first name, she gives me my first name. Yes! It’s me! She asks for my address. I give it to her. Then she swings a nifty computer screen to me, introduces me to a pen (which I get to keep), I pick up the pen and I sign my name on the screen.

Then another polling place person prints out my very own ballot, encases it in a big folder, hands it to me and directs me to one of those funky portable writing surface, where I use that pen to vote by checking off or filling in the little squares next to the names of my preferred candidates.

I’ve been reminded that on the opposite side of the ballot are two propositions. I flip my ballot and vote for the propositions.

I bring my ballot to the scanner, insert it and watch it sucked into the machinery.

There are no tables full of cupcakes being sold by school kids, so there’s nothing left for me to do but say goodbye to everyone and go home.

It is beyond my comprehension how voting has been made more complicated than this. I mean, I know who is trying to gum up the works and why, but I’m telling all you voters who don’t have the same sort of easy experience I have, get rid of the elected and non-elected officials who have set up barriers to your voting by forcing you to prove your identity beyond anything more complicated than signing your name on a computer screen.

 

Posted in Government, Politics, The Facts of Life, voting and voting rights | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Last week I voted. What happened?

Those heart-warming Consumer Cellular ads? Here’s the low down

I kept my polite, level tone throughout several hours of chats with Consumer Cellular help people. Until my last conversation, when the rep said “Have a blessed day.” I lost my stoic politesse. I snarled at him.

How did Christian religiosity enter a chat about problems I was having paying my bill to Consumer Cellular? Yes, that’s right. I was trying to pay my bill on line, as I’d always done, but Consumer Cellular’s web site wouldn’t let me pay my bill. Kept telling me they had no corresponding record of me and had I forgotten my password? I hadn’t but in the spirit of geniality made up a new one. Which they rejected.

Why did they care who I was? I was trying to pay my bill. I wasn’t trying to steal someone’s identity. I only wanted to pay my bill. Didn’t they want my money — whoever I was?

ℵ

Wait a minute. Lest you read this as a generic kvetch about cell phone services and passwords — which it isn’t — I’d better tell you about my life-long abjuration of cell phones. (Of course, by “life-long,” we’re talking not about the length of my life but about the life length of cell phones as ubiquitous objects clutched to frantic bosoms as dire necessities.)

The first time I grasped the intrusive absurdity of cell phones was when a friend was coming to my place for lunch. We’d made our date for some loose time, a whenever-you-get-here sort of arrangement.

Since she lived in my neighborhood, she was walking over to my place. At that time I lived on Perry Street, between Seventh Avenue and West Fourth. My phone rang; I picked up; it was my friend, calling from her cell phone to say she was at Seventh Avenue and Perry Street and would therefore be at my place in a minute.

What? Why had she called? I do not know. The only reason to call me in those circumstances would be to say she was on Seventh Avenue — like, lying in the street because she’d been hit by a rambunctious baby elephant and could I come over either to play with the animal or help her, my friend, get to St. Vincent’s Hospital. Which was, like my apartment, one block away.

I have never changed my mind about the silliness of cell phones. And since I’m scrupulously careful when crossing streets to avoid baby elephants, I am fixed in my idea that I do not need a cell phone. My world view does not encompass the fear I’ll run into trouble whenever I step outside my apartment and will be required to call emergency services at any moment.

The other day, one of my cousins was trying to come up with reasons why I might carry a cell phone. None of them made any sense to me. I told her there is only one reason I got a cell phone. I took a bus to Lambertville, New Jersey to visit a friend who was picking me up from the bus stop. My bus ran into problems and was an hour late. I couldn’t call her because I didn’t have a cell phone.

I felt guilty. So for future such occasions, I bought a phone, the cheapest plan I could find which, at that time, was ten bucks a month. When the price went way up, I dropped that service and hooked onto Consumer Cellular, at fifteen bucks a month which was actually twenty bucks a month, once they added in whatever it is they add in. Taxes? Fees? No-see-ums?

But I never carried the phone around with me because I still have no need to. I don’t call people when I’m walking around the city or shopping. I don’t call supermarkets to announce my imminent arrival. I’m still not running into baby elephants or other obstructions to my pathways. I have never needed having the weight of a cell phone in my pocketbook, never needed to yank it out, wait for it to warm up (or whatever it does) so I could call…who? What? Show friends pictures of my life via my cell phone? I have no pictures on my cell phone, because my Consumer Cellular plan did not provide enough data for pictures. Or texting. Or leaving messages.

And that is fine with me. My cell phone (a cute red flip ⇓) made a call, got a call and that’s pretty much it.

I used that cell phone ⇑ no more than five times a year, so I’d been considering another way of having a cell phone without spending fifty bucks per use.

That was the cell stage I was in when Consumer Cellular refused my payment.

ω

I called Consumer Cellular, which advertises itself as a happy family, especially for elder people who, it’s assumed, can’t really negotiate complex matters involving the internet. But what I’ve recently been seeing in their TV ads is a tell-tale expansion of their services from simple functions (like mine) to functions that mirror the complexity of pricey glamorous smart phone brands.

So maybe that’s what happened. Consumer Cellular is so wrapped up in getting smart and elaborate for its customers, it forgot how to maintain simple functions, like paying bills on its web site.

I spent an hour or so on the phone with eager, helpful people who kept saying they were so sorry regarding my inability to pay my bill. I was passed along to more and more advanced technological help but the techies proved as incapable of getting me online to pay my bill as did the sub-tech people.

The bottom line? Each of the Consumer Cellular helpers said, “I’m so sorry about this but I can help you pay your bill right now, on this phone call.” I rebelled. No, I said, I want to pay my bill on line. “Well…”

We got nowhere, so I said goodbye.

After once again attempting to pay my bill on line, I called Consumer Cellular to cancel my account. I got a person who did what all these services do when you want to cancel your account: he tried to talk me into a bigger and better account. I let him work his spiel for a while and then said, “Let’s just cancel my account.”

He did. And he reported he did and said I now owed Consumer Cellular thirty-two bucks. I said, “Send me the bill and I’ll see about paying it.”

And that’s when he offered (the invariably hostile), “Have a blessed day,” and I bawled him out for dragging his god into the conversation.

Next week, I’ll work on getting myself a burner phone and a small collection of sim cards. I fancy myself as a pseudo-spy, ripping sim cards out of my phone and grinding them into the ground lest my enemies trace my telephone call to my sister in Jersey, announcing when my bus will be arriving and where, so she can pick me up.

OK, that’s it.

Posted in Capitalism, The Facts of Life, The god problem | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments