Is “concierge medicine” ethical?

This is what a New York Times reader asked the Times ethicist a few days ago:

“Should I Feel Bad About Joining a Concierge Medical Practice? I can afford the membership fee, but I’m torn about the ethics of being part of this growing trend.”

Regarding “concierge” medical practices, this woman asked a pointless question, and got a lengthy dissertation on ethics by columnist Kwame Anthony Appiah. Which also was way off the point but Appiah, a professor of philosophy, isn’t a medical, science or business journalist who should have more and sharper things to say about “concierge” medicine.

Back in 2022, I was thrust abruptly into a personal experience with “concierge” medicine when my own internist went all “concierge.” I wrote about it and am linking my pieces, below.

There’s a lot to say about physicians who go “concierge,” and none of it is good.

But the best expert opinion was my sister’s. We call her Doctor Deb. She is a nephrologist in New Jersey and has grown fighting mad about the state of medical care in the U.S. Here’s what she wrote about it:

I agree [with me, about “concierge” practice] except to paint a slightly more jaundiced insiders view. VERY FEW of these concierge physicians deserve concierge fees. Too many are greedy mediocre physicians who always valued their income and lifestyle over commitment to delivering best care to their patients. I know of ophthalmologists and neurosurgeons who have reaped incomes in the millions of dollars each year. This is often way above paying the rent and malpractice costs. Many of my highly esteemed peers have been delivering what’s now labeled “concierge care” for years.

We were not facing economic hardship. We understood that the great satisfaction which comes from the best practice of medicine is sometimes worth more than dollars and cents. Most of our incomes were more than sufficient without “extorting” extra fees. Those who practice with caring are the physicians whom I hold in highest esteem. They are the many who went into medicine for all the right reasons: the honor of providing comfort and saving lives.

I do not mean to underplay the higher and higher costs of obtaining a medical education and those of staying in practice. These are mounting concerns for all of us. Economics are resulting in terrifying shortages of primary care physicians and some critical specialists who are perceived by medical students as working too hard for insufficient incomes. That is an entire other subject, i.e, training medical students in a “9-5” model of care.

Physicians missed the boat when they allowed themselves to be prostituted by big business. This completely deranged construct of the “business of medicine” which accepts profiting from others’ misfortune as perfectly fine, is what is destroying healthcare today.

Physicians should have understood that WE are the necessary foundation of high-quality care and should have unionized years ago. We should have demanded our rightful place at the head of the table to structure healthcare delivery and negotiate fair fees. We failed to do so due to many disparate goals and some unscrupulous greedy physicians there, too. To now make unwitting ill patients suffer in some game of musical chairs to reclaim power and an upper class CEO lifestyle is unconscionable and unprofessional.

Beware of this VIP con. This is extortion plain and simple in a world where physicians understand there’s a dreadful shortage of true professionals going into primary care and patients have no control over any of this mess.

The links to my own take-down of this subject:

Help! I Lost My MD, or How I Was Introduced to “Concierge Medicine”

What does “concierge” medicine claim it offers us patients for the exorbitant annual fee? And why the claim is devious and disingenuous, sort of like TV ads for many drugs.

“Concierge” medicine, the last sales pitch. (Or was it?)

It wasn’t.

I want to emphasize that this “business model” called “concierge” medicine was not developed by your physician. I’ll say it again: the letters and pitches I received were from a company, i.e., a profit-making company. So call this insidious thing what it is: a capitalistic con job, a sales pitch for a “product.”

The initial con is upon our physicians, the ones who are foolishly flattered by the slimey business pitch. I’m going to guess that these companies’ first approach to the physician says something about “for a small percentage of your newly high earnings.”

What?! You don’t think these companies are embracing physicians’ incomes out of generosity and kindness and concern for patients’ well-being, do you?

Posted in Capitalism, Medical care in the US, The Facts of Life | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Is “concierge medicine” ethical?

A devastating description of a monarch who sounds like Trump.

If you scrape the rubbish-heap of servile, coeval flattery that usually smothers the personality of a monarch you will discover a few kings who have been truly great; many who have achieved greatness because they were wisely content to serve as masks for the great intellects of their time; and for the rest, some bad kings, some foolish kings, and some ridiculous kings. But in all that royal gallery of history you will hardly find a more truly absurd figure than that of the resplendent Roi Soleil…

I am not aware that he has ever been laughed at; certainly never to the extent which he deserves. The flatterers of his day, inevitable products of his reign, did their work so thoroughly that even in secret they do not appear to have dared to utter — possibly they did not even dare to think — the truth about him. Their work survives, and when you have assessed the monstrous flattery at its true worth, swept it aside and come down to the real facts of his life, you make the discovery that the proudest title their sycophancy could bestow and his own fatuity accept…makes him what indeed he is: a king of opéra bouffe. There is about him at times something almost reminiscent of the Court buffoons of a century before, who puffed themselves out with mock pride, and aped a sort of sovereignty to excite laughter; with this difference, however, that in his own case it was not intended to be amusing.

A heartless voluptuary of mediocre intelligence, he contrived to wrap himself in..”a terrible majesty.” He was obsessed by the idea of the dignity, almost the divinity — of kingship. I cannot believe that he conceived himself human. He appears to have held that being king was very like being God, and he duped the world by ceremonials of etiquette that were very nearly sacramental.

I wandered into this grand slam of Louis XIV, the Sun King, by Rafael Sabatini from an odd 1924 volume of Sabatini’s writings entitled The Historical Nights’ Entertainment. (Because I’m well versed in at least one of the stories, I can verify the historical accuracy of them.)

The chapter from which Sabatini’s story concerning Louis XIV is called “The Night of Witchcraft: Louis XIV and Madame de Montespan” — two historical figures I recently got entangled with through Alexandre Dumas’ five-volume musketeers epic. (Dumas is somewhat gentler to Louis and his mistress than is Sabatini. Sabatini is more accurate.)

I wonder how Sabatini would describe Trump and his absurdly hideous attempt to imitate Versailles with his “golden ballroom.” I don’t think he’d call Trump “of mediocre intelligence.”

A few pages later in this chapter, Sabatini describes what happened after Madame de Montespan became official chief mistress to Louis. I read this as a warning to the Trump family — over their greed and colossal enrichment:

…Madame de Montespan was firmly established as maîtresse en titre, and in January of 1669 she gave birth to…the first of the seven children she was to bear the King. Parliament [pay careful attention, Republicans in Congress!] was to legitimize them all, declaring them royal children of France, and the country was to provide titles, dignities, and royal rent-rolls for them and their heirs forever. Do you wonder that there was a revolution a century later, and that the people, grown weary of the parasitic anachronism of royalty, should have risen to throw off the intolerable burden it imposed upon them? 

I don’t wonder. Let’s all agree that, given the lightening speed of our global communications, it will not take a century for us to rise against our very own pseudo-royal parasites.

Posted in The Facts of Life | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on A devastating description of a monarch who sounds like Trump.

Why? That’s the only question

I saw the news about Trump grabbing an oil tanker which brought up the only rational question around: why?

Oh, we’ve gotten a reason but the reason was superficial — words skidding over the surface. In fact, the reasons we’re offered for any question about why this mob group, sometimes known as The Administration, is doing what it’s doing in demolishing and wrecking our government is the opposite of “reason.” It is irrational.

“We’re tearing up the government because the government is too big.” What do you mean by “too big?” Why have you decided it’s “too big”? Where’s the evidence of its too-bigness?

Why have you sent mischievous incompetents to hack into our computerized services? For fun?

Why have you commissioned and uniformed violent mobs to pick up and make disappear loads of people? Their answer is along the lines of, “They’re illegal.” Well, a lot of them are not “illegal.” And anyway, so what? They’re working, supporting themselves and us, contributing in all ways to this country’s treasure. So “they’re illegal” isn’t an answer. It’s not a rational policy, a reasonable reaction to…well, nothing, because there’s no reason they’re doing it. (Rational people say that the constant demonstration of cruelty is why. But Grand Guignol performances are utterly superficial, if horrible. And it’s not scaring most of us, so…why are they doing this? Why?)

Trump’s criminal wranglers get him to tell the cameras, “There’s a really good reason, believe me,” or something like that. I don’t believe him. I don’t believe any of them. In a way, this eases up on my intellectual life. Whatever they say, I flip it over and assume either the opposite is true, or there’s nothing there at all, which frees me to pick up the history books I’m reading.

These bizarro people are in effect stupid, six-year-old bad seeds, now grown-up (stupid) sociopaths, whose answer to “Why are you breaking up the furniture with an axe?” is “Because I want to.”

Why? is the only rational question right now. Which does not mean what follows will be a rational answer.

 

 

Posted in Corruption, Fascism, Immigration, MAGA, Politics, The Facts of Life, The filthy rich, Trumpism | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Why? That’s the only question