The coup de grace for Rudy Giuliani

It’s not the only reason to read the Daily News, but the lead editorial in today’s paper is entitled:

Rudy Awakening

Posted in Law, suits and order, Lawyers, Politics, The Facts of Life | Tagged , | Comments Off on The coup de grace for Rudy Giuliani

Why did it take so long to suspend Rudy Giuliani’s law license?

That is the question a number of people on Twitter were asking today.

Really, given the quality, experience and education of the people I follow, well, they should know better. Apparently their impatience overwhelmed their common sense.

However, lookie here! I just uncovered one of my files containing the record of my own legal complaint against a lawyer who represented me in a personal injury case. So I am ready to explain why this process takes so long. Or, in common parlance, I’ve got the receipts.

First, let’s correct a common error: in New York, where Rudy is licensed, it is not a bar association which suspends or removes a lawyer’s license to practice. It is the administrative division of the state appellate court. In Manhattan, this administrative division is called the Departmental Disciplinary Committee.

A grievance filed against a lawyer must be by someone or some entity in a position to be aggrieved. An ex-client, for instance. Several complaints against Rudy were supported by New York bar associations and filed by heads of several bar associations.

The grievance itself takes time to prepare. You don’t simply send a “this lawyer is a POS disgrace to his profession!” letter. The grievance must contain: (1) an overview of the problem; (2) a chronology of the problem, specifying the things the lawyer did or didn’t do to cause the grievance; (3) a summary; and (4) attached relevant exhibits.

And before I, personally, did anything, I read the entire Rules of Professional Conduct because I had to complain about actual breaches of the actual Rules, not my general irritations.

My really simple complaint consisted of 7 single-spaced pages and 8 exhibits. Doesn’t sound like much but it took me time to compile it.

Now, think about Rudy Giuliani. Think about the months it must have taken to compile all the TV appearances, articles quoting him, court filings he made, all the times he may have violated the Rules…and on and on and on. Thousands of pages of exhibits (including videos, I’m sure).

What happens after the grievance is filed (if I remember, nine copies of it)? Well, the accused lawyer gets to respond! To do so, he probably hires a law firm to do the work. And the law firm has to make a statement and compile exhibits which can dispute the statements in the initial filings.

Then the Disciplinary Committee sends the respondent’s answer to the complainer, with a cover letter saying:

If you disagree with the attorney’s statement, please write us, telling us specifically how and why; if you have any documents substantiating your points of disagreement, forward them to us. Also, please tell us what has happened in regard to this matter since the time you filed the complaint.

If we do not hear from you within twenty (20) days, we may conclude that you agree with the attorney’s statement.

Oh, I had disagreements! So I wrote another statement (24 pages), citing specific disagreements, with another bunch of exhibits (seventeen of ’em) and a table of contents. (My favorite was exhibit 11, a Daily News story with around ten arrest photos, about a bust of an ambulance-chasing ring based at a local hospital. One of the photos was of the lawyer I first met when I signed the retainer.)

Here is the time span over which my grievance proceeded: initial filing, April 18, 2012. The response was dated July 2, 2012. My reply was dated July 18, 2012.

The decision of the Disciplinary Committee (more than fifty people are on it but I assume grievances are assigned, possibly at random, to a select small group) was dated March 13, 2013.

My dinky little grievance, which did not succeed, took over a year.

The complaints against Giuliani are not dinky.

And that’s why it took so long to suspend Rudy’s law license.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted in Law, suits and order, Lawyers, Politics, The Facts of Life, Trumpism | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Why did it take so long to suspend Rudy Giuliani’s law license?

What I want for every voter is what I’ve got

In the New York primaries, I voted early. It was the first time New York had granted early voting.

This year, also for the first time, we had ranked choice voting.

Last year, because of the pandemic, I voted by mail.

Today in the Daily News, I read a letter from a man who said he’d voted in Manhattan. He described his experience this way: he walked into his polling place. He told a poll worker his address and was pointed to the correct table for his district.

He gave the poll worker at the table his name and address. The worker entered his name into her computer. His name, with a signature line, popped up on a computer screen facing him. He was told to sign his name with his finger. (I doubt it; I was given a ballpoint pen, told not to open it but to sign with the blunt nib. I did. I used the same pen to mark my ballot. I got to keep the pen.)

The Daily News letter writer then said he could understand the GOP’s demand for voters’ ID everywhere because had he known a neighbor, say, wasn’t going to vote, he could have supplied the neighbor’s name and address and voted for him.

No; he couldn’t have. Unless he’d practiced forging his neighbor’s signature perfectly, which he could not have accomplished. (I know the trick for forging signatures but the particular format at election precincts would not permit this trick.)

And in fact the letter writer must have had what could be called “voter ID,” because I did. Several months before the primary, I received in the mail a card from “Vote NYC.” It is the size of a credit card, has my name and address on it and a bar code at the bottom. To the right are two numbers: my election district and my Assembly district. The instructions with the card told me to present it at my precinct to make the process quicker and more effective.

So I did. And I was instructed to place the card on a marked rectangle on the table. It was photographed and immediately my voting information (with signature line) popped up on that computer screen — the one I signed with the blunt end of the pen.

I suppose the Daily News letter writer got that card but paid no attention to it, because clearly individual cards were sent to all registered voters.

Still, even without the card, he gave his name and information at the table and signed the computer screen.

The way elections have always worked for me in New York:

  • My voting place is an elementary school three blocks from my building.
  • I have never, even during presidential elections, waited on line more than fifteen minutes. And my neighborhoods are big turn-out neighborhoods.
  • For months before each election, I’ve been reminded dozens of times about the voting processes, including voting by mail and voting early.
  • I received a card which facilitated and sped up the voting process but it wasn’t mandated that I present that card. It was for my benefit, not the state’s.
  • The only real ID I needed was my name and address, and then my signature on the computer screen. I have every reason to believe if my signature did not match the years of my signatures in that computer, someone, probably one of the police officers stationed at the polling place, would have approached me with a frown.
  • After signing in, I was handed a two page ballot, with a reminder that three sides of the ballots had candidates so I wouldn’t miss anyone.
  • I went to a little open booth/desk where, at leisure, I looked over the ballot and then voted.
  • I then took my ballot to a scanner and fed it in. Whoosh! Whoosh!

The only thing missing this year (early voting was not held at the elementary school) was the luscious table of cookies and cakes sold by the students, where I could buy a home-baked cupcake on my way out. In the general election, I’ll be voting where and when the cupcakes are.

As I read about the grotesque voting regulations being shoved through GOP state legislatures, I marvel at how obviously twisted and bizarre all this contemptible and, I hope, unconstitutional nonsense is, given how easy it is for me, and millions like me, to vote securely.

I want everyone in this country to be able to vote as I do, with trust that if the Daily News letter writer tries to vote for his neighbor, he’ll be immediately detained.

Posted in Fascism, political campaigns, Politics, The Facts of Life, voting and voting rights | Tagged , , , , , , | Comments Off on What I want for every voter is what I’ve got